Role Models…

23 10 2008

I must admit, when I heard the news that Joey Barton, the footballer, wanted to act as a role model for young people, I was hugely skeptical about the whole idea. I mean, what parent in their right mind would want to leave their kid in the company of someone who has, on more than one occasion, assaulted people and done jail time for it? I don’t think I would ever have called Barton a role model. There are many things that he is, violent, dangerous, unpredictable, short-tempered. But not a role model. This is, remember, the guy who stabbed a lit cigarette into the eye of a younger professional at a christmas party.

So what sort of role model could he be? “Here’s how to get banged up. I’m a footballer, I can get away with it, but you kids won’t. You’ll do longer sentences because you aren’t famous.” Hmm. Truly inspiring. It’s not like the guy is particularly renowned for his speaking abilities either (some footballers, incidentally, are, Beckham for example, after all these years, is still as rubbish as he ever was, but Steven Gerrard, despite being a scouser, does speak well to the press I feel). No, Barton is just not role model material.

He is someone who has been given so many ‘second chances’ that he must be nearer his one-hundred-and-second chance than his second. Barton was, and, I believe, will remain a thug, both on and off the football pitch. You get them in all walks of life, the playground bully, the office bully, the coffee shop bullies if you remember Friends, the wife-beaters (or indeed husband), children-beaters. Bullies are not uncommon in the world. Barton is just a public bully. Except that he isn’t just a public bully at all. He is a public bully who keeps getting away with it. Which is very definately worse. What sort of example is that to set to young people? What sort of mis-representation will that give of our legal system, which for all its flaws, still does not resort to execution as a means to an end?

There is the argument that Barton himself is trotting out, running along the lines of ‘changed man’. Which is interesting. Rudyard Kipling told us that the leopard could not change its spots. Nor indeed the Ethiopian for that matter. I don’t think Barton will either, despite time in jail, and despite vowing to be a different person.

Citing his experience in jail as one of the reasons people can connect with him, Barton has told reporters that he hopes to reach those who were unreachable before. Hmm. Despite my reservations, no, my complete dislike, of Barton I think he may have a point. There are many people who feel footballers do belong in a different, squeaky-clean world full of celebrity culture and the high life. Those who shun such attention (Paul Scholes and Micheal Owen for example) have the reputations of being well-mannered, polite family men. Which is a far cry from the growing gang culture of major cities. At least Barton can try to connect with people from shared experience (alcohol abuse, violent conduct, jail time) and try to help them improve their lives. Just as he is, apparently, trying to improve his. It remains to be seen how successful Barton is during his career (at 26 time is on his side as a professional sportsman), but I think of more concern to everyone is how successful Barton is in his own life.




One response

23 10 2008
Jeff Levy

Barton has escaped what others in many industries have to endure.
I believe wholeheartedly that repeated thuggery in sport has got to be stamped out and if this man commits any other act on or off the pitch, the message should be clear; that a total ban must be issued.
Football has been overhauled greatly in the past few years, but a certain ambiguity surrounding this obviously violent person says just as much about the authorities as they do about Barton.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: